Solutions for Payer Peer-to-Peer Reviews
Payers’ growing reliance upon artificial intelligence (AI) to deny claims shifts high-quality medical documentation into an increasingly integral role in reimbursement. When payers deny claims, medical documentation becomes the evidence physician advisors use during peer-to-peer (P2P) reviews. Quality medical documentation increases the likelihood of overturning denials during the short reconsideration review period.
“When an admission is denied, the reconsideration review period is the closest thing to a gift from a payer that a hospital will ever get,” according to Franklin Baumann, MD, the CEO of AppriseMD. Having a consistent process in place to manage these denials efficiently and promptly produces measurable reimbursement dollars that maximize the revenue cycle.
The next question becomes who handles this process? Many hospitals use internal teams or attending physicians to facilitate reviews. However, this extra effort can too be onerous for physicians busy treating patients and hospital revenue cycle managers in need of quick fixes for large numbers of claim denials. For hospitals that rely on attendings or in-house staff to engage in P2P reviews with payer medical directors, contracting with a company to provide backup support offers consistent revenue integrity assurance, denial mitigation data, non-completion statistics, and clinical, payer and regulatory expertise.
1. Revenue Integrity Assurance
Having a partner available to manage overflow P2Ps ensures hospitals can seize every opportunity to get paid for provided medical services. Outsourcing denial recovery removes the process from the provider’s plate but does not compromise revenue optimization. Partners who provide physician advisors with extensive clinical and payer experience manage the entire process from reviewing the cases denied and scheduling the discussion with the payer to providing a report that includes a clinical summary, an overview of the discussion with the payer medical director and the outcome. Physician advisors solely focused on denied claims are especially effective when weak documentation triggers the now frequent medical necessity denials detected by automated claim review systems.
Additionally, hospitals should look for partner companies that do not require any software installation or require maintenance fees that often come with software purchases. This ensures hospitals only pay for what they need.
2. Non-Completion Statistics
Ensuring all P2Ps are completed quickly is essential for recovering revenue. P2P opportunities evaporate if an otherwise engaged physician misses the call from the insurance company while attending to patient care or the team is short staffed. High-volume periods when patient reviews pile up in a work queue for a level of care (LOC) recommendation can cause missed opportunities as well. There are myriad reasons why providers neglect P2Ps, but every skipped P2P results in lost payments. The best-case scenario for missed P2P opportunities is a lengthy formal appeal process that significantly delays recoupment even if it is successful. Both cases disrupt the revenue cycle, adding more work to teams already working at capacity.
3. Denial Mitigation Data & Consistency
A consistent approach to managing the P2P process includes capturing and tracking the denial data. Documented reviews should include a brief clinical summary, outcome, and recommendations on next steps if the payer upholds the decision. If the P2P results in an upheld decision, the physician advisor should provide a recommendation as to whether he or she believes the hospital should file a formal appeal. Hospitals utilize this documentation when deciding whether to file a formal appeal and when drafting the appeal. The upheld outcomes incorporate the reason the payer did not overturn the denial and whether the payer was compliant with guidelines, arming the appeal teams with information for the formal appeal.
4. Clinical, Payer & Regulatory Expertise
“U.S. hospitals lost an estimated $13.2 billion in net revenue to bad debt and final insurance denials in 2025, according to a Nov. 4 analysis from Kodiak Solutions,” Becker’s Hospital Review recently reported.1 With insurance denials recognized as part of this revenue leakage, all hospitals should ensure P2P reviews are handled by physician advisors who possess multiple years of experience in utilization management, clinical practice and regulatory compliance. Further, hospitals can capitalize on the national data that companies specializing in physician advisory services possess.
Summary
Healthcare reimbursement is a priority, and ensuring appropriate payment shouldn’t be left to chance. The P2P review provides an opportunity for health systems and hospitals to engage with payer medical directors to overturn denials and get paid. A partner who manages overflow P2P reviews acts as a stopgap for revenue leakage. Health systems and hospitals exploring overflow assistance should look for partners who do not require minimums, employ board-certified physicians, and do not require any software installation.
Sources
1. Condon, Alan, “Hospitals’ $132B revenue leakage problem,” Beckers Hospital Review, Nov. 10, 2026.
AppriseMD provides fee-for-service physician advisory coverage 365 days a year and only employs US-based, board-certified physicians to engage in the P2P reviews with payers. Additional AppriseMD resources on this topic include:
- The Use of AI in Claim Denials, which delves into the class action lawsuits against three health insurance companies using AI to deny claims without examining patient records.
- Protection from AI-Driven Payer Denials, an exploration of featured medical necessity and risk concepts that can be leveraged in clinical documentation to sustain revenue integrity and patient care. The strategies proposed in this publication build the footing for preserving patient care and the financial integrity of the healthcare delivery model.
