Overturning Denials

Difficult inpatient-stay denials

operation, operating room, doctor

CLINICAL SUMMARY: Bilateral Pneumonia

A 23-year-old nonverbal female patient arrived in the emergency department with her parents who said she had a fever and heavy breathing since the morning. The patient’s medical history included Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome, severe mental retardation, seizure disorder, recurrent aspirations, recurrent pneumonia and vagal nerve stimulator. Her parents said she had been suffering with flu-like symptoms for the previous week. However, she had no cough, vomiting or abdominal pain. It is noted that the patient was not physically able to cough. She had been vaccinated for COVID-19 and received a booster as well as the influenza vaccine.


This case study involves a 54-year-old female patient with a past medical history of type I diabetes, diabetic gastroparesis, nephrolithiasis, hypothyroidism, hypertension, and traumatic brain injury. She arrived in the ER out of concern for diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA). The patient was hospitalized for DKA one month before this admission. She had been sick with nausea, vomiting, upper abdominal pain similar to prior gastroparesis attacks and was unable to take her insulin for several days. On the day of admission, she started noting blood sugars greater than 400 on her monitor at home, as well as a very dry mouth, and the inability to stay hydrated. The patient had no fever, chest pain, shortness of breath, or cough. In the ER, there was generalized abdominal tenderness and tenderness in the right upper quadrant and epigastric area. There was no rCVA tenderness, guarding or rebound. Her vital signs were as follows: temperature max 100 degrees F,  pulse 102-126, respiratory rate 16-20, blood pressure 112/63, oxygen saturation 100% on room air. A chest x-ray was unremarkable. Her labs had the following results: WBC 14.54, Hgb 15.3, platelets 494, Na 128 (135 corrected for glucose 464), K 5.2, CO2 11, BUN 21, Cr 1.32, osmolality 289, VBG pH 7.11, β-OH butyrate 91.30, Glucose 76-493. Urine analysis: + glucose, + ketones.


This case involved an 83-year-old female patient with a known history of chronic COPD on 4L supplemental oxygen via nasal cannula, DVT, gout, multiple falls, hypertension, and anxiety. She arrived in the emergency department with complaints of shortness of breath that had gotten worse over the previous 24 to 48 hours, especially on exertion. She said she was out of breath earlier in the day with self-measured oxygen saturation in the low 70’s. She increased her oxygen to 5L without significant improvement. She did not have a cough, fever, chills, nausea, or any vomiting. Patient also reported intermittent chest pain under the left breast that felt like ‘something catches’ and was impacting her breathing.


This case involved a 74-year-old patient who presented with chills and a temperature of 103°F. The patient had a past history of hypertension, arthritis, and right total shoulder replacement in January 2021. Chest x-ray showed coarse perihilar and interstitial markings, likely viral or reactive. A CTA chest was negative for pulmonary embolism or acute pulmonary disease. A urine test was nitrate positive with trace leukocyte esterase. Blood cultures were drawn, and urine was sent for culture.


This case centers around a 59-year-old female who arrived at the hospital ER with ‘tightness’ and left-sided chest pain that began at rest. The patient said she has had similar pain several times over the last month. She suddenly awoke with severe left lower quadrant pain, which is a chronic issue for her IBS/colitis, that night. Shortly after her abdominal pain started, she reports left-sided chest discomfort with associated nausea. She said she has a large amount of stress at home.

CLINICAL SUMMARY: Suicidal Ideation

A 47-year-old patient was admitted for an intentional drug overdose, suicidal ideation, anxiety depression and alcohol abuse. Past medical history showed the patient suffered from bipolar disorder, anxiety depression panic attacks. The ER report stated the patient arrived via EMS after taking one bottle of benzodiazepines along with alcohol but was alert. The patient was admitted to a step-down unit with 1-on-1 sitter for suicidal and seizure precautions.


A 36-year-old new mother with a recent C-section was admitted after an ER visit due to shortness of breath occurring since the delivery of her child and drainage from her surgical incision. The patient had a significant past medical history of morbid obesity, asthma, and sleep apnea. The physician summary showed the patient had acute toxic respiratory failure due to asthma exacerbation.

CLINICAL SUMMARY: Acute Diverticulitis

A 69-year-old female with past medical history of atrial fibrillation, aortic/mitral valve replacement, chronic anticoagulation, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes mellitus, neuropathy, GERD, COPD. The patient was admitted to the hospital with chief complaint of abdominal pain and bright red blood per rectum. The CT of the abdomen pelvis showed diffuse colonic bowel wall thickening compatible with colitis/diverticulitis.

CLINICAL SUMMARY: Cardiac Ablation

A 79-year-old patient was scheduled to have an elective cardiac ablation which went well, but the patient developed hypotension post procedure. In a previous ablation procedure, the patient had a similar response post ablation with hypotension requiring several days of hospitalization. The most recent hypotension required Levophed. The patient was also diagnosed with a UTI prior to the ablation and antibiotics were on-going.


Patient was admitted to the hospital for orbital cellulitis IV treatment. The patient presented with left eye redness and pain with movement, especially over the left gaze. There was no history of recent trauma. Maxillofacial CT showed mild left globe proptosis with preseptal edema, mild rectus enlargement with possible surrounding fatty stranding. As per ophthalmology patient was thought to have possible orbital cellulitis and placed on broad-spectrum IV antibiotic therapy. The patient, who also had a history of drug abuse, decided to leave against medical advice while being treated.


An 80-year-old patient with a past medical history of atrial fibrillation, arthritis, congestive heart failure, COPD, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, history of PE, pacemaker GERD, arrived in the Emergency Department with chest pain which had been occurring for a week.


A 48-year-old male patient was admitted for fluid overload with symptoms of shortness of breath and weakness due to missing hemodialysis appointments. The patient had a significant past medical history of hypertension, dyslipidemia, atrial fibrillation, end-stage renal disease and was on hemodialysis three times a week. When admitted, the patient was also complaining of a recurrent abscess in the mouth previously drained but not treated due to a missed follow-up. The patient was admitted for incision and drainage of the abscess and IV antibiotics.

CLINICAL SUMMARY: Oropharyngeal Cancer and Alcohol Withdrawal

Patient with SCC oropharyngeal cancer was admitted to the hospital with alcohol withdrawal. No beds were available at a detox center; therefore, the patient was brought to the Emergency Department for help.


Patient with a history of asthma and a high BMI was admitted with asthma exacerbation and a wound infection.

CLINICAL SUMMARY: Total hip arthroplasty

A 66 year-old patient undergoing total hip arthroplasty. The patient received an ASA score of 3, having multiple comorbidities including asthma and need for postoperative supplemental oxygen therapy.


Can Peer-to-Peer reviews overturn short hospital stay in-patient denials? We have done a limited study and seen the benefit of P2P reviews at AppriseMD and how it can reverse denials and recoup dollars for hospitals.

Scroll to Top